American Horror Story has been bringing characters back since its fourth season back in 2014, Freakshow. It was at this time that Ryan Murphy revealed that all the seasons take place in the same universe, contrary to the anthology format. Since then, characters like Queenie, Constance, and Pepper have each popped up again (albeit briefly).
With AHS: 1984 right around the corner, who knows how Murphy will continue this trend. Perhaps after the massive crossover of Apocolypse, Murphy might take a step back from the spillover approach. But, in the event it continues, here are ten characters we would love to see make a comeback.
Twisty
Twisty was an immediate fan favorite when he first appeared in Freakshow. This gigantic hulk of a villain was arguably the most frightful to ever appear on the series. So it was a shame when he was taken away only a few episodes into the series, dying off and being swept away by Edward Mordrake.
So, what better way to rejuvenate him than to bring back his ghost? Perhaps it is a bit to supernatural, but the serial killer aspect of 1984 looks like it could make some room for it. Or, maybe a copycat killer in the same vein as Dandy Mott?
Edward Mordrake
Edward Mordrake certainly was an odd character in Freakshow. This deceased freak with two faces helped transport the dead to the next realm, assisting multiple characters in the fourth series. The idea never really paid off very well in the show, as Mordrake never embodied a very frightening persona.
A potential scenario might see that 1984’s killer could be taken away by Mordrake during the finale. Who knows? If they plan on continuing a shared universe style of storytelling, they need to keep the continuity going.
Mr. March
Since 1984 is embracing the slasher genre, maybe the show should go back to its roots. Mr. March was essentially the first slasher, murdering hundreds in the Hotel Cortez. Based on the real-life serial killer H. H. Holmes, Mr. March built an elaborate maze of terrors into his hotel to trap them inside.
Who knows how he could be worked in? It just feels right to reunite all the serial killers together in this show. Besides, Hotel did it already in their Halloween special.
The Guests Of Devil’s Night
Speaking of “Devil’s Night,” maybe this is how the seasons could be tied. 1984’s killer will need to fall at some point during the season. When he does, maybe he will make a trek back to the halls of the Hotel Cortez, mingling with the worst killers of all time.
“Devil’s Night” is one of the best episodes of AHS to date. The casting and performances were perfect and really showcased the obsession the series has with true crime. It would be a welcome surprise to send this season’s killer to dinner with the likes of John Wayne Gacy and the Zodiac.
Larry Harvey
When it comes to the eighties, there aren’t as many previous characters who could show up as one might think. Most of the seasons are either set too far in the future or way back in the past. Because of that, some of these characters might seem a little random.
So is the case with Larry Harvey, the Harmons’ disturbing and violent neighbor in Season 1. Harvey, as played by Denis O’Hare, was one of the more underrated villains of the show. Just seeing Denis O’Hare back at all would be welcome, and Larry should be alive during the time of 1984’s events.
Lana Winters
Ok, maybe the Lana Winters horse has been beaten to death. She has appeared in one whole season, been referenced in others, and appeared in an episode of Roanoke. Obviously, fans love her arc, but how much more could you feature her?
Well, maybe one more time couldn’t hurt? Maybe she could appear as a reporter investigating the murders at this summer camp. It is not outside the realm of possibility considering her experience. It would be a fun way to include a beloved character for a final hurrah.
The Angel of Death
Frances Conroy is one of the most valuable players in American Horror Story. She has brought some of the most iconic characters to life on the series, including Moira and Myrtle. One of her least remembered appearances was as the Angel of Death in Asylum.
This entire idea was barely explored in that season and has not been picked up since. It would be a fun way to connect the two seasons and continue the mythology that was put forth with her inclusion. Also, can’t we just get more Frances in everything?
Constance Langdon
Did we just get her back last season? Yes. Does Jessica Lange want to return to American Horror Story anytime soon? Probably not. Does she even have a reason to appear in the upcoming 1984 season? Absolutely not. Do we care? Not one bit.
Jessica Lange’s best performance on the show was as Constance Langdon. Carrying just enough sympathy to balance the more bitchy tendencies, Constance was such a fascinating character to follow. Just bring Jessica back, and we know everything will work itself out (can you blame us for dreaming?).
Bloody Face
Bloody Face was absolutely disturbing in Asylum, no matter the iteration. The first Bloody Face, Dr. Thredson, died during the events of that series; however, his son lived to the present day. So, what happened between those two periods?
When did Lana and Thredson’s evil son take on his father’s mantle? It would be horrifyingly shocking to center 1984 around his first kills, making him the one who is terrorizing the camp.
Stevie Nicks
OK - Fleetwood Mac and Stevie Nicks are primarily associated with ’70s music, even if both continued releasing material throughout the next few decades. In American Horror Story, Nicks is a witch who has been working her magic since 1966.
Why can’t Nicks show up in the upcoming season? It’s not as if no one was listening to the band during this era. Maybe she can come in and actually show off more of her powers? Less bonkers things have happened on this show than a witch disrupting some summer camp murders, and you all know that.
